Better teacher appraisal and feedback: improving performance

by Ben Jensen

A new system of teacher appraisal and feedback would improve teacher effectiveness, recognise our best educators and lift the outcomes of Australian students to the best in the world.

This report combines an analysis of international research with extensive interviews with educators in order to propose a new system of appraisal and feedback to meet teacher, parent and public concern.

It examines eight methods of teacher appraisal and suggests that schools use at least four of them to effectively appraise teachers’ performance through a balanced scorecard approach. It argues that teacher appraisal and feedback must be decentralised, with individual schools given autonomy and responsibility so that they can assess their own teachers.

Better teachers are the key to producing higher performing students. The report shows that systems of appraisal and feedback directly linked to improved student performance can increase teacher effectiveness by as much as 20 to 30% — with a big impact on the outcomes of Australian students, which are currently in decline.

Download Report

Download Media Release

Download Implementation toolbox for schools

Download Implementation toolbox for governments

Download a copy of op-ed published in The Australian

Related Articles


05 February 2017

Engaging students: creating classrooms that improve learning

Australia’s education system needs comprehensive reform to tackle widespread student disengagement in the classroom. As many as 40 per cent of school students are unproductive in a given year. Un…


06 February 2017

The hidden problem in our classrooms: unproductive and unengaged students

Published by the Sydney Morning Herald, Monday 6 February There is a big problem with student behaviour in the classrooms of Australia. But it is not the aggressive or even violent behaviour tha…


05 May 2017

Engaging students: creating better classroom environments for learning – Adelaide

Event Podcast: In this event, in partnership with the State Library South Australia, Dr Peter Goss, Grattan Institute School Education Program Director, hosted a panel of leading educators to explore…