Exploitation of migrant workers is a national shame
by Brendan Coates, Trent Wiltshire
Migrants were front and centre during the worst of the pandemic, in our hospitals, cooking meals, stacking the shelves. Yet too many migrant workers are exploited in Australia. It needs to stop.
Exploitation hurts migrants, but it also weakens the bargaining power of Australian workers, harms businesses that do the right thing, damages our global reputation, and undermines public confidence in our migration program.
The scandals and exposes have been coming for years.
An investigation by The Age and Four Corners uncovered $173 million in underpayment of workers at 7-Eleven outlets, many of them international students. Some were being paid as little as $10 an hour.
Our new report, Short-changed: How to stop the exploitation of migrant workers in Australia, shows that the problem remains widespread. Up to 16 per cent of recent migrants are paid less than the national minimum wage.
Local workers aren’t immune either: Our research shows that up to 9 per cent of all workers in Australia were paid less than the minimum wage in 2022.
Overall rates of underpayment fell during the pandemic, because of the departure of many temporary visa holders, the introduction of JobKeeper, and a strong jobs market. But we risk underpayment rising again now that the borders have reopened and many temporary visa holders are returning. Now is the time for the government to act.
Three sets of reforms are needed to stamp out the exploitation of migrant workers.
Change visa rules
First, visa rules that increase migrants’ risk of exploitation should be changed.
Many temporary visa holders put up with mistreatment out of fear that their visa will be cancelled or they will lose their pathway to permanent residency if they are found working in breach of visa rules.
Temporary skill-shortage visas should be made portable, so migrants can flee from an exploitative employer.
The government’s recent decision to require employers to pay sponsored workers at least $70,000 a year will help reduce exploitation as higher-paid workers typically have more bargaining power.
Australia’s working holiday visa program has drifted away from its original goal of promoting cross-country cultural exchange towards being a supplier of cheap labour on Australian farms.
Rules that force working holiday-makers to work in regional areas to extend their stay in Australia should be abolished. Instead, working holiday-makers should be limited to a single one-year visa – what Australians are entitled to abroad.
The government should commission a review of international higher education in Australia, with a brief to identify ways to reduce student exploitation and weed out dodgy course providers.
And the government should create a workplace justice visa, to enable migrants to remain in Australia for a limited time to pursue unpaid wages if their temporary visa is about to end.
Strengthen workplace laws
Second, workplace and migration laws should be strengthened and better enforced to deter exploitation.
Few employers who underpay their workers get caught, and the penalties are far too small when they are caught.
Employers who underpaid their workers were hit with penalties of just $4 million in 2021-22, compared to $3 billion collected by the Tax Office from tax offenders, and $232 million imposed by the ACCC for breaches of competition and consumer law.
If we don’t take wage theft more seriously it will keep happening.
The Fair Work Ombudsman – Australia’s workplace cop on the beat – should be renamed the Workplace Rights Authority and be given greater powers and an extra $60 million a year to step up enforcement of workplace laws.
It should have the power to fine employers who underpay their workers, not just those who fail to keep the right pay slips.
Maximum court-ordered fines for underpayment should be increased. And courts should be able to send employers who knowingly underpay their workers to jail for up to 10 years.
Support exploited workers
Third, more support should be offered to migrant workers who pursue their employer for unpaid wages, because right now too few exploited workers try to get their money.
Migrant workers centres should be established in each state, to help educate migrant workers about their rights and connect migrants with suitable legal advice if they need it. And funding for community legal centres should be boosted.
Australians are rightly proud of our heritage as a migrant nation.
But the mistreatment of so many migrant workers is a national shame. It’s time we stamped out the exploitation of migrant workers for good.
While you’re here…
Grattan Institute is an independent not-for-profit think tank. We don’t take money from political parties or vested interests. Yet we believe in free access to information. All our research is available online, so that more people can benefit from our work.
Which is why we rely on donations from readers like you, so that we can continue our nation-changing research without fear or favour. Your support enables Grattan to improve the lives of all Australians.
Danielle Wood – CEO